Customer reference calls sit at a strange intersection. They are not a sales pitch. They are not a technical deep dive. And they are never neutral.
By the time a buyer asks for one, the deal is already leaning in one direction. The call either confirms the decision or quietly kills it.
That is why reference calls deserve far more care than they usually get.
The biggest mistake is treating them as a formality.
Hand over a customer name, schedule the call, and hope for the best. Hope is not a strategy here. You are placing your reputation in someone else’s hands. You owe both sides preparation.
The most senior logo is not always the best choice. What matters is similarity. Same industry. Same scale. Same problem. A buyer wants to hear themselves in the story. If they cannot, the call feels interesting but irrelevant.
A good reference knows what is coming. Not what to say, but what context matters. Remind them why the prospect is calling. What stage they are in. What concerns are likely to surface. This is not scripting. It is respect for their time.
The call itself should never start with praise. That feels staged and immediately triggers scepticism. The most credible opening question is about the problem before the product. What was broken. What was frustrating. What forced the change. Buyers listen closely to that part because it mirrors their own discomfort.
When the product comes up, specifics matter more than success. What took longer than expected. What surprised them. What they would do differently. Honest friction builds more trust than polished wins. A reference who admits trade offs sounds real. Real beats perfect every time.
There are also landmines to avoid.
Never bring a reference into a call cold. Never let sales dominate the conversation. Never jump in to correct or reframe what the customer says. Silence is powerful here. Let the reference speak in their own words, even if it is messier than you would like.
Another quiet risk is overusing the same reference. Fatigue shows. Stories get shorter. Enthusiasm fades. Rotate references and give them breathing room. Gratitude goes a long way. So does closing the loop after the deal, whether you win or lose.
A reference call is not about convincing. It is about reducing fear. The buyer is looking for permission to trust their own judgement.
If the call does its job, the decision feels less risky when the line goes quiet.
That is the art.
Leave a Reply